Choosing a Knife – the Right Knife for Your Needs

bowie-knifeYears ago I had this acquaintance who always carried this big assed Bowie on his hip no matter where he went and one day I got curious and decided to ask him what was the reason – the answer surprised me and I will share it and other information I think you’ll find interesting.

Robert was called Red for obvious reasons; he stood 6’-4” in his stocking feet and sported a stocky 250# frame and his Budweiser Uni-pack as he referred to it. He was in the habit of carrying a bone handled Bowie knife with a blade the length of my forearm on his hip in a handed tooled leather sheath with his name RED on the outside. It was a big knife 15-inches or so long with a razor sharp blade.

I knew Red for about a year when I got up the nerve to ask him why he carried such a big blade.

“It’s the best overall utility knife I have ever owned. I use it in my carpet business for cutting carpet, for chopping when my boy and I hunt, for cleaning our game we catch and for many other things it’s been invaluable.” He said.

That got me to thinking when I began to write this article. What is really needed in a knife?

The answers are first comfort, utility and price. Let’s take each point individually.

Comfort – It’s obvious most people would not feel comfortable with a 15-inch knife on their hip. A more practical method is a folding blade that can clip on the inside of a pants pocket not leaving it exposed to view and weighing only ounces.

Utility – Utility is one of the most important things in owning a knife.

Owning a knife for personal protection alone is a foolish notion. I have been alive for 62 years and being in the business I’m in placed me in situations that could have gotten precarious and not once was I forced to pull a knife on another person.

So let’s discuss the utility factor. A knife is meant for cutting purposes and one you would carry can be a fixed or folding blade.

Fixed full tang blade knives – these are the most practical for utilitarian purposes as they are strong one piece blades with a handle attached. They are usually 8”-10” in length and can be used around the house, in a business capacity similar to what Red used his for and when hunting, camping or fishing to chop small branches for a fire, pry items, cleaning fish and game and to cut rope and the butt end to hammer in items.

Folding blades with a locking mechanism – A good utility blade is one that can be kept in your pocket or clipped to your belt for small cutting jobs. This type of knife usually has no more than a 4-inch blade is suitable for light duty on your job if required, camping, hunting or fishing serves a dual purpose and yes can be used as personal protection.

Price – This is something no one ignores not in today’s questionable economy. If you go online you’ll see blades from $10 to $500 but let’s be practical what is reasonable?

A decent fixed blade knife that will work in almost any situation shouldn’t cost more than $50 and will likely last you a lifetime. A good folding blade with a firm gripping surface, a strongly attached blade, easy to open and strong locking mechanism (very important) will run about the same $50. When it comes to fixed blade knives my selections are easier SOG and Gerber have been the most comfortable and utilitarian.


Gerber fixed blade camping knife



SOG Tactical folding knife

I won’t recommend any in particular but SOG, Gerber, Buck, Benchmade, Kershaw and Case are my top choices. I have owned each over the years and for a utility knife they were all excellent. As a tactical blade I prefer and carry a SOG but that is personal choice not because it’s better than any other.

When you shop for best knife for a survival situation I suggest you buy both a fixed blade and a folding blade. Check the folder by opening it several times, does it have an open assist to help, is the blade firm and not able to be moved side-to-side or in any way with pressure? It should be firmly locked and comfortable in your hand.

The fixed blade should have a 5-6-inch blade, a handle that won’t slip when in heavy use, should have a tang than runs the length of the handle as well and fit in your hand comfortably.





  1. Reply
    KelleyNBranter July 13, 2015 at 1:03 pm

    Great web site. Lots of useful information here. I am sending it to several pals ans also sharing in delicious.
    And naturally, thank you to your sweat!

  2. Reply
    KristenCTrembly July 24, 2015 at 2:34 pm

    Hello there, You have done an excellent job. I will definitely
    digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I’m sure they’ll be benefited from this site.

Leave a reply